Day 2 of the fourth Ashes Test at the Melbourne Cricket Ground was overshadowed by a major controversy that left Marnus Labuschagne visibly frustrated. The incident occurred in the 18th over of Australia’s second innings when England pacer Josh Tongue found the outside edge of Labuschagne’s bat, sending the ball sharply to the slip cordon where Joe Root claimed the catch.
Labuschagne stood his ground, appearing unconvinced that the ball had carried cleanly to Root. With uncertainty surrounding the catch, the on-field umpire sent the decision upstairs. After reviewing multiple replays, the third umpire ruled in England’s favour, concluding that Root’s fingers were underneath the ball and that it had not touched the turf. The decision did not sit well with Labuschagne, who walked back to the pavilion clearly disappointed.
Marnus Labuschagne's exit adds drama to England’s fightback
What did you make of this catch? Out or not out?#Ashes | #DRSChallenge | @Westpac pic.twitter.com/pnWo2qt6qc
— cricket.com.au (@cricketcomau) December 27, 2025
The controversial dismissal came during a dramatic collapse that saw England bowl Australia out for 132 on a seam-friendly surface. With sideways movement on offer throughout the day, England’s pacers exploited the conditions superbly, leaving themselves a target of 175 to seal a rare Test victory on Australian soil. By the time stumps approached, 30 wickets had fallen in just four-and-a-half sessions, underlining the bowler-dominated nature of the contest.
Australia resumed the day at 4/0 with a slender overall lead of 42 but quickly lost their grip on the game. Travis Head top-scored with a vital 46, but his dismissal triggered another slide as Usman Khawaja departed for a duck and Alex Carey followed soon after for four. The hosts slipped from 82/3 to 88/6 in the space of a few overs, placing England firmly in control.
Ben Stokes produced a crucial spell after lunch, removing Cameron Green for 19 to finish with figures of 3/24, while Brydon Carse cleaned up the tail with an impressive 4/34. Earlier in the match, Josh Tongue’s career-best 5/45 had bowled Australia out for 152, before Michael Neser responded with 4/45 to restrict England to 110 and hand the hosts a 46-run first-innings lead.