Table of Contents
Cody Rhodes had been pushed as a main event star ever since he made his return to WWE back in 2022 during WrestleMania 38. He had some amazing matches throughout the time since he returned to WWE, and he also Main evented three consecutive WrestleMania events.
But what had been the favourite match of Cody Rhodes himself? There were definitely a lot of matches to choose from, both of his WrestleMania main events with Roman Reigns had been amazing. The series of matches with Seth Rollins was also 5 star quality performances.

Which one is Cody Rhodes' personal favourite match since his return
But Rhodes believed that his first WrestleMania main event with Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 39 had been his best match in WWE since his return to the promotion in 2022. Recently, he appeared on the Bill Simmons Podcast, where he explained why his WrestleMania 39 match with Roman Reigns was his personal favourite. Here is what the American Nightmare had to say;
Cody Rhodes main evented three consecutive WrestleMania events
“My favorite match is WrestleMania 39, which is the one where it doesn’t happen. probably would have been pumped to win, but there’s something about that night where things were happening in the stadium that had never happened to me. [Roman]’s got me in the guillotine choke.
“You hear these old timers, and God bless him, I love them, talk about ‘just stay right there and the people will react and they’ll go.’ When you’ve seen the amount of cool flips and awesome stuff, sometimes that’s that seems like maybe that’s not real anymore.

At WrestleMania 39, Cody Rhodes was defeated by Brock Lesnar
“Then in that moment, I remember I’m just slowly wiggling my head out and I can hear an entire stadium where the sound goes up, start to move. And I thought, ‘Oh man, they’re into this.’ How blessed am I that they’re into this? And when it’s that good, it feels completely real. Everything seems real. Roman is the greatest enemy of my life. I’m trying to climb a mountain that’s impossible to climb. Just that acoustic moment for me, it made it my favorite match of all time.”
Check out why Sami Zayn's storyline with Karrion Kross here
Rhodes might have favoured his WrestleMania 39 match with Roman Reigns, but the majority of the fans would still favour his WrestleMania 40 match, and that is only because of it being extremely overbooked, which made it one of the most entertaining WrestleMania main events for all time. But his match with John Cena from WrestleMania 41 would definitely be the worst of the three.